And Jill Came Tumbling After
from Womankind (1971)
(Editors Note: The author had twins: one boy and one girl. The
way these two children grew up is indicative of the challenges parents
face raising children in a sexist society.)
My children,
girl and boy twins, are only two years old. It may seem that sexism
couldnt yet have been much of a problem. Instead, Ive
found that normal dealings with babies include many sexist
attitudes and behaviors guaranteed to stunt the growth of any human
being.
Sexism
showed up very early. In fact, my twins appearances at birth
were an embarrassment to some well wishers. Rachel weighed two
pounds more than Adam and his hair was longer than hers. Not one person
who saw then lying next to each other told me what a big, strong daughter
I had or how very delicate my son was. In most peoples minds,
when the right compliment is attached to the wrong sex, it ceases
to be a compliment. What people did notice and comment on was that
Adam was far more active than Rachel.
They said: Hes a little man already. Since my childrens
activity levels were predisposed in traditional sex role directions,
I was always explaining that it was only chance and could have been
the other way around. lt was frustrating, because, with Womens
Liberation a hot controversy in the mass media, people translated
the fact that one boy was more active than his twin sister into the
final word on the question. Of course I (and they) knew baby girls
who were very active and boys who lolled around all day. Every time
this kind of boy moves at all, someone says, Hes such
a little man.
There
were also behaviors that I had to overcome. I found myself poking
my head in Rachels crib and saying, Hows my sweetie?
My husband would call her a princess. At first, we only called Adam
little man. When other people called Rachel a honey
and Adam a fine boy even their tone of voice was different.
To her they spoke softly and sweetly, and to him they used the kind
of gruff voice that fathers use with their sons. I could feel a more
direct warmth in the first, a holding back, teasing, and rough quality
in the second. This voice difference made me angry because it seemed
obvious that Adam needed more soft sweetness in his life since he
was active and kind of nervous, and Rachel could have used the stimulation.
But human needs aside, the input was already being selected for the
roles they would be expected to fill later.
Our initial
tendency was to be physically rougher with Adam. We threw him in
the air from the time he was a month old. But we had to remember
to roughhouse with Rachel, which was her favorite activity too. People
would caress and cuddle Rachel, while Adam would get a playful jab
in the ribs. A person's sense of her body depends on how people treat
her. Of course it makes a difference if you are treated like a glass
statue or like a prize-fighter.
For gifts,
Adam got overalls and denim pants. Rachel got many fancy dresses.
If you dress a girl up a lot because you want her to look pretty,you're
also going to care a lot more how dirty she gets. Youll be more
likely to pick her up off the floor when she gets to a dirty place.
Cleanliness becomes an important part of her image. No wonder shell
be less explorative, even afraid of new challenges. What image are
we after when we dress our girls in frills? lts a kind of Christmas
tree appeal.
She (the
person) is there in the middle, while hung about her are all the
ornaments to admire. A boy is dressed simply, and the same holds
for Rachel and trucks. Playing with cars and trucks has already made
her interested in all kinds of motor vehicles. She doesnt have to become a
truck driver, but I would like her to feel comfortable with machines.
Everyone knows we live in a technological age, but so far only men
can relate to a machine.
There
are many more aspects of sexism in the first two years. The most
crucial is probably the way people in the family whatever kind of family
it is relate to each other, and what they do with their lives.
Also, I have many unresolved questions. Adams hair has reached
a length where even hippies think he is a girl, and I dont know
whether that is a good reason to cut it.
When
I finally put a dress on Rachel last spring, she started to cry,
presumably from unfamiliarity. I realized two things: one, theres nothing
wrong with dresses sometimes, and two, I would be afraid to raise
a daughter who was that uncomfortable in a dress.
These
little incidents reflect a far deeper dilemma I dont want
my children to feel like freaks, but I also dont want to condemn
them to repeat our past mistakes and suffering. I think the best answer
is to provide our children with a community of peers with similar
values so they are not alone.
The exact
solutions to many sexist problems are not easy to find. But for ourselves
and all our children, to struggle is essential. Having girl
boy twins has made it clearI and others contribute, either to
creating onehalf a personality in each child, or a whole human
being in both.